I went to another local kitchen store the other day. Just to see what cabinets they carried, and if they could compete with prices at Kitchens Plus. And the kitchen designer decided to GIVE ME ANOTHER PLAN TO CONSIDER. NOOOOOOOO. Here I thought I had decided everything, and now she's telling me I need to change it all around?? WE WILL NEVER GET A KITCHENNNN!!!!!
Anyway, here's the plan she suggested:
Good things about this plan:
1) In every other plan, our stove has remained in the same place (which has my back to the kitchen/dining). Putting the stove in the island would let me see the children while cooking.
2) Kitchen triangle is smaller than when the fridge is on the far wall.
3) That island is huge.
4) Feels very open - the walkway to the hallway isn't obstructed at all by fridge/pantry as in other plans.
Ok, yes, it looks nice and open, BUT there are several issues. Big ones.
1) The space between fridge & stove is only 53ish inches. A bit tight if one person is cooking and someone else (say, a small child who wants water) has to get into the fridge.
2) We would have to get a very specialized (read: expensive) oven and/or a very expensive hood.
3) This is probably the most important: the giant size of the island would shrink the width of the dining room to only 8.5 feet. That is not good. Recommended minimum for dining area is at least 9 feet. We have a narrow table and the room already feels cramped; add some people sitting at the counter and no one would be able to get through the space at all!
I'm going to sleep on it a bit, but I'm pretty sure that this will not be our final kitchen layout.
Probably still something like this.... with or without the island overhangs...